jump to navigation

Is ATF Providing Due Process on NFA taxes? May 23, 2012

Posted by federalist in RKBA, Taxation.

Here is a picture of the federal government depriving citizens of due process. Federal law requires payment of a $200 tax to make or buy certain types of weapons. The ATF is responsible for collecting the tax and returning a stamped form showing the tax has been paid and the applicant is allowed to make or receive the weapon. The ATF cashes the check on receipt of the application, but this chart shows that they are taking longer and longer to return the stamp — now upwards of six months.

NFA Wait Time Trend as of May 2012
(Source: http://www.randominfo.net/NFA/WaitTimeTrend.php)

Background: The 1934 National Firearms Act imposed a $200 tax on manufacture or transfer of a large class of firearms and accessories deemed at the time to be “gangster” weapons. In then dollars the tax was so high that it effectively eliminated the civilian market for machine-guns and silencers.

Through the quirks of subsequent court decisions, laws, and regulations, “short-barrel” rifles (SBRs) and shotguns (SBSs) are also subject to the NFA tax, but the delineation of these controlled items is truly bizarre. For example: Handguns are exempt, no matter what length barrel. But if you put a stock or shoulder support on a handgun with a barrel under 16″, it becomes a SBR. If you cut a rifle’s barrel under 16″ it’s an SBR, unless you remove the stock, in which case it’s a pistol. But if you add a foregrip to that, it becomes another type of NFA item called an AOW (“Any Other Weapon”) which requires a $5 tax.

In 1986 the Firearm Owners Protection Act froze the supply of machine-guns that could be transferred to individuals. The values of such transferable guns have run into 5 figures, so they are now mostly collectors items. People who want to legally play with machine-guns have to either be very wealthy or pay a Special Occupation Tax (typically at least $1000/year) to establish themselves as manufacturers, and subject themselves to license and regulation by the ATF.

Fortunately, the NFA tax rates stand at their original levels, and thanks to inflation it is no longer particularly difficult to pay the $200 to transfer or register a silencer or SBR in the majority of states where it is legal. In recent years hundreds of thousands of such tax stamps have been purchased as citizens have rediscovered the safety and convenience of silencers and SBRs.

A delay was always part of this process, but while many people were willing to wait a month or two for NFA paperwork to be processed, fewer are willing to go through the ordeal when the delay approaches a year. If government requires you to pay a tax to conduct commerce, its constitutional obligations to provide due process do not permit it to collect the tax and then withhold approval for an unreasonable period. Obama’s ATF has certainly crossed the line.



1. federalist - August 8, 2012

Of course, forget Due Process: For some classes of firearms the ATF can classify them as “Destructive Devices” just because they feel like it. The Striker 12 is arguably a less effective 12-gauge shotgun than a Saiga with 25-round drum magazine. But the former is a destructive device. Just because.

2. Alan magoraski - September 18, 2012

Just because. Logical

3. Due Process Update: NFA Tax | Federalist - January 3, 2014

[…] This is worse than it was last year. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: